CELTIC fought back from 2-1 down in a pulsating end to end game against Hibernian to make it 2-2. However, the bhoys may feel aggrieved by Willie Collums decision not to award the home side a penalty after Scott Sinclair was clearly fouled in the box.

Is Scott Sinclair’s honesty and determination to stay on his feet his downfall here as Collum waves play on after the Englishman is manhandled.

Should this have been a penalty?

20 COMMENTS

    • What planet do you live on? The rules do not say the player has to look for the penalty.

      The Foul in the box makes the penalty, Not whether the player asks for one. There were three fouls, two separate pulls to the body the third was when Efe grabs him by the neck. What are you playing BBC Rules?

  1. Willie Collum can have no defence for anyone calling him to account for not giving this penalty kick. He was very close to the offence and had the ideal angle to judge what was going on. He should have the “courage” to declare “I got it wrong”, although this should leave him open to accusations of being a total tit. He is not (imo) biased or prejudiced, just incompetent.

    • Sam, I used to think that, now I believe he is a cheat, pure and simple.

      Look at various bad offences against Celtic and he is reluctant to act or minimises the punishment. McLean, Millar, Halliday and the young boy, all reds the young guy got off with a yellow then promptly repeated the foul… No action taken. Look how long it takes him to take action.

      Now go and look at Him when he gets a chance against Celtic, the card is out quicker than a gunslinger draw in the old western movies.

      He is a cheat. Pure and simple, that does not mean that he is promoted above his ability, it just adds to the p*as poor performances.

      He should be demoted. What will happen in our set up? He will get a semi or final at least.

  2. Collum is a cheat pure and simple.
    The number of times he breaks the rules against Celtic is actually amazing.

    Think of last season, THREE offerings off in the one game against PretendyGers, how many given? NONE.

    Yet how many times have you seen him pull that red card against Celtic, how many quick wrong decisions against Celtic, how many blatant for the other team?

    I read someone excuse him because he is “religious” so we’re the Pharisees in the bible… They were full of their own sh#t too.

  3. Collum having his usual Lodgy Eye Sight……And this Cretin is meant to be a Referee.At the end of the Day,No matter how many lodgy dodgy decisions go against us.The Leagues Ours.Spose to be an Even Playing Field.Here is another Scumbag who plays by his Rules…Mans a Turd.

      • Hence he has to keep himself on the right side of the Beaks, for fear he gets , ach he is a catholic hence he is partial. Celtic is a non religious club, after all do Ranagiars not have more Kaffollics that the Celolic? Listen this guy is not different from Michael Curry- remember him any one?

      • I don’t see what that has do do with him being a CHEATING incompetent.

        Are you claiming the wee dick is infallible?

        What a p*ss poor excuse that is… he is a Catholic…was he straight up to the Confessional on Saturday evening?

        He is a Cheat, I hope it despite being a Catholic, rather than because he trying to impress or overcompensate.

  4. I hope whoever is in charge of referring watches Saturdays game and demotes Callum it’s not only Celtic but other clubs he has no idea how to referee a game if I were Celtic I would refuse to play in any game he was involved in if all the teams refused to play when he’s in charge the SFA would have to do something it’s disgusting the way he went on on Saturday and can have a bad effect on the results of games get him out

  5. Never seen such a blatantly obvious penalty for a long time. Collum had a perfect view! Talk about corrupt officials! Utter disgrace that we have such blatant corruption.

  6. Shame they didn’t break the mould after making Bilbo Madden. It appears they also made Willie Gollum with it too. 🙁

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.