Former Hearts midfielder and BBC Scotland pundit Michael Stewart has hit out at the performances of Ange Postecoglou’s central defenders this campaign.

Writing in his Sun Sport column, Stewart begins by stating his beliefs that the defensive side of things hasn’t been good enough, particularly in Europe.

He also continued, stating that neither Cameron Carter-Vickers or Carl Startfelt are good enough for the level which the Hoops have been playing at this campaign.

“CELTIC have come a long way in a short time under Ange Postecoglou.

“But after shipping another three European goals, there’s still no case for the Hoops defence.

Postecoglou’s side have played five group games in the Europa League this season and conceded 13 goals. Add in the qualifiers, and it’s 20 in 11 matches.

“The 2-0 win over Ferencvaros at Celtic Park was pretty routine, but the four others weren’t.

“They lost 4-0 to Bayer Leverkusen in Glasgow, 4-3 away at Real Betis, 3-2 in Germany on Thursday and, unfortunately for Postecoglou, the only high-scoring thriller they won was their 3-2 triumph in Budapest.

“It’s been entertaining — but it’s totally unsustainable.

“You can’t keep losing goals like that if you want to make progress in tournaments at that level.

“The Celtic boss is on record as stating the January transfer window will see more additions to his squad.

“Top of his list should be a top-class central defender. Maybe even two.

“I can’t really remember a window when I didn’t feel Celtic should strengthen that area. It’s been neglected for a long time.

“Even Brendan Rodgers’ side had a weakness in central defence.

“Dedryck Boyata and Jozo Simunovic were better than what they have now but still didn’t convince in Europe.

“So far this season, Cameron Carter-Vickers and Carl Starfelt have been Postecoglou’s first-choice duo. For me, neither is good enough.

“I hear people saying the Spurs loan man has been a great addition. But if Celtic want to progress at the European level, they need better.

“Judging by his words, Postecoglou is fully aware he needs to strengthen his defence. The way Celtic have struggled to keep clean sheets in Europe probably won’t be a surprise to him.

“People will talk about his system and how expansive Celtic can be, but that’s not why they’ve conceded goals. It’s down to an inability to defend well enough when they go up a level in the Europa League.

“There’s a false debate that you can’t win if you play a really attacking style.

“You can, but you need to defend your box well and do the basics right.

“Look at the goals they lost late on Thursday night. Nobody can say Celtic left themselves too exposed. They had plenty of bodies in the box at both goals, but they didn’t react in time. They were slow and got punished.

“It was nothing to do with structure or tactics — it was about not being switched on to danger.

“Celtic are being coached really well right now and if they can find better quality in defence, they will definitely develop as a team.”

There is no denying that in Europe this season, we could have been a bit better with some of the goals conceded at points.

However, to me, this feels like a harsh point to be making, considering the fact we are arguably playing our fourth choice centre-back at this stage and have also seen many changes in the backline this season.

Additionally, Ange’s side is also currently the best defensive side in the Scottish Premiership.

The points about CCV and Starfelt are also very strange to me, given how impressive both have started to look within the backline at this point of the season.

Is there room for improvement? Absolutely. But at the same time, the improvements are there, and at such an early stage in Ange Postecoglou’s era as manager, I believe there is still a lot more to come from this group of players.


  1. I think he’s right about the defence except, CCV is good enough if the right player is beside hime. Anthony Ralston looked out of his depth for the first time in terms of his defending for me …and I have been a long-term believer that he is a lot better than given credit for, However, is this a step too far ?

  2. This defensive problem is easy to sort out.At corners,put one of the smaller,weaker guys on each post instead of getting in the way and standing looking at each other when the ball goes to either side of the goalie into the net.Secondly,put your big,strong guys along the six yard line ready to launch forward to attack the ball when it comes over,goalie can come out to clutch or punch clear knowing there are players behind him to clear any balls that manage to elude him and the tall defenders.See,piece of this coaching gig.I’ll email John Kennedy and see if they’ll sign me in the Jan window.My personal terms will be easy to negotiate because I love Celtic….

  3. Too much emphasis on blaming the centre backs for losing goals. Ralston and Juranovic both gave balls away to give Leverkusen chances. Every Celtic fan knows the defence needs improving right across the back but giving Taylor a long term contract doesn’t help. Young Welsh makes too many mistakes but could learn with experience but all said I am sure Ange is fully aware of what he needs so let’s get behind him


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.