Rodgers’ Big Call in Defence

Soccer Football - UEFA Europa League - Red Star Belgrade v Celtic - Rajko Mitic Stadium, Belgrade, Serbia - September 24, 2025 Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers REUTERS/Marko Djurica

With Cameron Carter-Vickers ruled out for up to five months after suffering an Achilles injury against Sturm Graz, Brendan Rodgers faces a significant selection call at the back.

Celtic’s defensive mainstay will be missing through a crucial run of fixtures, starting with Sunday’s top-of-the-table clash against Hearts at Tynecastle.

Rodgers described the news as “not great” but insisted the setback offers a platform for others to seize their opportunity. Liam Scales is expected to retain his place as the steady presence on the left side of central defence, but the identity of his new partner remains open — and the choices are intriguing.

Auston Trusty would seem the most experienced option. The American international arrived from Sheffield United last summer for around £6 million and has already featured in domestic and European action. Strong in the air and aggressive in duels, Trusty brings a physical edge similar to Carter-Vickers, though he has endured his own injury interruptions since joining the club. If fit, he offers Rodgers a like-for-like solution with proven senior pedigree.

Alternatively, the manager could turn to youth. Dane Murray’s form on loan at Queen’s Park last season earned him a new contract through 2028, and the 22-year-old’s composure on the ball has caught the eye since returning to Lennoxtown. A home-grown defender breaking into the first team would resonate strongly with supporters, particularly in a period where Celtic need fresh energy and hunger.

Dane Murray of Celtic on the ball
4th July 2025; The City Stadium, Glasgow, Scotland; Pre Season Football Friendly, Queens Park versus Celtic; Dane Murray of Celtic on the ball

Then there’s Jahmai Simpson-Pusey, the highly-rated 19-year-old Manchester City loanee. Tall, athletic and comfortable stepping into midfield, he represents a modern centre-half profile that Rodgers values. While untested at Premiership level, his potential is clear, and a strong showing in training could fast-track him into contention.

Celtic’s defensive strength has long been built on stability and understanding. With Carter-Vickers sidelined, Rodgers must find a new partnership to carry that standard. Whether it’s the experienced Trusty, the developing Murray, or the exciting Simpson-Pusey, the opportunity is there, and someone will need to grasp it quickly.

5 COMMENTS

Comments are closed.